Welcome to the final part of the series in which we go through the process of plugging Steamer’s Rest of Season (RoS) projections into your existing ranking/dollar value spreadsheet so you can make informed and objective roster decisions during the season.
If you register as an SFBB Insider (it’s free), you can receive the entire series in an easy-to-use e-book (also free) along with two other helpful guides. I’ve also written a comprehensive guide on ranking players and calculating player dollar values that’s available at Amazon.
Introduction
In this sixth part of the series we will revisit the concept of replacement level and adjust replacement level for our updated RoS projections.
Reminders About Replacement Level
If you’re new to the concept of replacement level read the introduction here (don’t go into the “Step-by-Step Instructions”. When you consider the injuries that occur in Major League Baseball, rookies being called up, players underperforming projections, and others exceeding projections, the player pool is constantly changing.
In order to make the best possible decisions and to calculate representative dollar values, it is very important that we update the estimate of replacement level.
Caution: No Further Adjustments Necessary
When listening or reading fantasy advice, you might come across a piece of advice that goes something like this, “You really need to draft a SS early to account for the lack of depth at the position. Go ahead and reach for that shortstop.”
Don’t listen to that advice when you’re using the approach we’re now going through. The replacement level adjustment that follows is already calculating the effect of depth at each position. And it does it mathematically. There is no guesswork going on here.
DON’T MAKE ANOTHER ADJUSTMENT.
You do not need to make an arbitrary adjustment to shortstops or catchers, or any other position. When you have added this adjustment to your rankings, each player will be ranked according the their value over the worst players at the position. If the position is weak, that’s accounted for. If the position is deep, it’s accounted for.
If you then decide to make arbitrary adjustments to your rankings after adding in the replacement level calculation, YOU ARE DOUBLE COUNTING.
You will be reaching for players and you will be hurting your team. Don’t “bump” players up a list because of their position.